Thirty-five years after he delivered a Saturday Night Live monologue dressed like a turkey, Paul Simon proved he still has surprisingly sharp comedic timing as a "guest" on SNL's fake BET talk show What Up With That? this past weekend. We all saw the inevitable coming -- everyone gets played off What Up With That? as that is the whole point of What Up With That? -- but Simon underplayed his small part perfectly, and looked genuinely delighted when Kenan Thompson said something actually unexpected: "Ladies and gentlemen, this is exciting. Put your hands together, for another Lindsey Buckingham!" Fleetwood Mac's actual Lindsey Buckingham joined his alter ego (played by Bill Hader) onstage and fingerpicked a bit of "Big Love," thereby upstaging host Ed Helms, who'd plucked a mean banjo a few minutes earlier as Captain Sexy Banjo. Sorry, Ed Helms, but that was kinda the story of the night for you, wasn't it?
Song One: "Rewrite"
+2 for bringing what has to be a record five acoustic guitars