Last night, the top 11 "American Idol" contestants sang the songs of Elton John (who was of course too much of a diva to actually show up, although I still hold out hope for a surprise Elton appearance on tonight's results show). And today, my Yahoo! Entertainment colleague Matt Whitfield and I have plenty of burning questions. Such as...
Did Casey Abrams redeem himself? Was Casey's "makeover" the most anti-climactic in reality television history? Why did almost everyone perform safe ballads, and why didn't anyone have the guts to cover "The Bitch Is Back"? Did James Durbin inadvertently start a cola war by plugging Coke's arch nemesis, "X Factor" sponsor Pepsi, on live TV? What was up with Naima Adedapo's weird Jamaican accent? Is my boy Paul McDonald in trouble? Can next week's theme PLEASE be '80s Night? Who wears the better Elton glasses, me or Matt? And, most importantly...which two contestants are going home tonight?
Check out our convo below--and be sure to join in by posting your comments, too!
Follow Yahoo! Music:
- Casey Abrams