Last night, Ashthon Jones was the first Season 10 "American Idol" finalist to be eliminated, and while this wasn't exactly a shocker of Daughtry-esque proportions, my Yahoo! Entertainment colleague Matt Whitfield and I still have plenty to discuss on today's episode of "The Day After."
Such as: Did Ashthon have ANY chance in Hades of earning that Judges' Save? Should she have sung a different song from the one that landed her in the bottom three in the first place? Will the hospitalized Casey Abrams be well enough to continue in the competition? And most importantly, did the right person go home this week?
Check out our convo below--and be sure to join in by posting your comments, too!
Follow Yahoo! Music: