Last night on "American Idol," awesome frontrunning rocker James Durbin was sent home in fourth place, and it was the most shocking elimination since Pia Toscano was voted off in the top 9 week. And in today's installment of "The Day After," my Yahoo! Entertainment colleague Matt Whitfield and I have some conspiracy theories as to why this happened, and why Season 10 is shaping up to be "Idol's" most unpredictable season ever. (Spoiler: #itsrandyjacksonsfault)
Check out our heated convo below--and be sure to wish Matt a happy birthday today, because having one of our favorite contestants go home this early is a pretty crappy birthday present.