Last night, the "American Idol" top five show had a "Divas" theme, but the biggest divas were the ones behind the judging table, Nicki Minaj and Mariah Carey, catfighting as usual. (Simmer down, sirs!) Onstage, the top five girls were actually less than divalicious, making my "The Day After" cohost Matt Whitfield and I question if this whole "girls' season" thing was such a good idea after all.

Today, we talk about last night's show, and predict whether the judges will use the Save on whichever girl is in jeopardy, no matter who it is. So simmer, down, sirs, watch our latest chat, and feel free to add your own thoughts to the comments section below.

photo: Kristen (Jower-Ho) ShafferFantasia--one of the greatest contestants from "American Idol," who is about to release her excellent fourth album, Side Effects of You--incredibly won the show nine years ago, and much has changed since her Season 3 victory. Until recently, Season 3 had been the most girl-powered season in "Idol" history (the only season to feature a girl-vs.-girl finale and an all-female top three), and soon after that season, "Idol" became a very male-dominated affair. But now, in Season 12, we have an all-female top five, which makes it so fitting that Fantasia is returning to the show to perform this Thursday.

Swinging by Yahoo! while in L.A. this week to discuss her evolving career and the evolution of "Idol," Fantasia was reluctant to name her favorite Season 12 contestant, but she did coyly remark, "Let's just say there's a young lady on there that's right around the corner from me, South Carolina [Editor's note: She means Candice Glover, y'all], and I think she's pretty good!" But Fantasia had advice for all five girls, telling them, "Keep good people with you, stay focused, and don't let the industry or anyone try to change you. Be who you are, and actually enjoy this."

Sarah Sellers [photo: Justin Goode]Season 10 "American Idol" alum and cool food blogger Sarah Sellers has been posting her viewing-party snack recipes in Reality Rocks for two "Idol" seasons now, and she's back this year to get your mouth watering every night of Season 12.

Tonight, one of the themes for the top five "Idol" finalists is "Divas," so Sarah is going with classy, feminine finger food suitable for the classiest of cocktail parties. Enjoy!