Last night, the top 12 "American Idol" girls performed on the big stage for the first time, and it was such a good episode that my Yahoo! Entertainment colleague Matt Whitfield is still home recovering from all the excitement (and prepping his outfit for tonight's beyond-exciting "American Idol" finalists' party, of course; these things take time). But thanks to the magic of speakerphone technology, Matt is still here in spirit to discuss all of last night's highs and lows, in today's edition of "The Day After."
We'll be reunited tonight at the "Idol" soiree, where we'll be shooting on location for the very first time...but in the meantime, check out our top 12 girls convo below--and be sure to join in by posting your comments, too!
Follow Yahoo! Music: