Stop The Presses!

Dec.21-27: ‘Idol’ Rumors And Idle Threats

Lyndsey Parker
Stop The Presses!

This Christmas week, American Idol fans has visions of jumping sharks, not sugarplums, dancing in their heads as Simon Cowell's own brother Tony perpetuated rumors that season 9 will be Simon's last stint on the popular TV talent show. In an installment of Tony's podcast "The Cowell Factor" that has since been mysteriously pulled off the server, Simon's sibling blurted out: "A press statement is being prepared which will confirm what everybody expected: Simon will leave Idol at the end of 2010 to concentrate on bringing the American version of [his British talent show] X Factor to U.S. TV in 2011."

While the news earlier this year of fellow judge Paula Abdul's resignation from AmIdol certainly generated shockwaves in the music/TV community, that commotion quickly subsided once it was announced that the much-loved Ellen DeGeneres had been hired to take Paula's place. But the immediate reaction among Idol watchers this week was that NO ONE could ever replace Simon Cowell, whose "surly British judge" persona set the template for reality TV during this decade (see: Nigel Lythgoe, Piers Morgan, Gordon Ramsey, Len Goodman, et al) and has always been a crucial component of American Idol's appeal. Surely the show could not survive the departure of the judge everyone loves to hate and hates to love. That's why Simon is  paid the big bucks ($35 million a year), right?

Well, as of this writing, no one from Fox or 19 Entertainment has come forward to directly and officially address these resignation rumors. But The Hollywood Reporter reported this week that Fox is close to a deal to renew Idol for three more seasons (after its contract ends in 2011), with or without Simon's involvement. (Perhaps this is why Fox, according to the Hollywood Reporter, is contemplating having Simon still fill a smaller role on Idol season 10, like weighing in during Hollywood Week, in order to keep people tuning in.) So, does this mean Paula will get her old job back? Will Simon be replaced by Ben Folds, who immensely impressed as a judge on this month's The Sing-Off? We shall see. But American Idol will never be the same sans Simon. We all might as well set our DVRs for The X Factor U.S. now, if this rumor of his departure is true.

In other Simon Cowell news, his unbroken run of music business domination was finally broken this week--by a 17-year-old Rage Against The Machine song, of all things. See, the "Christmas number one"--the song that tops the charts at the end of the calendar year--is a big deal in Britain, and for the last few years it's been all but guaranteed that the honor will go to the most recent X Factor winner's debut single. But this year, 2009 X Factor champion Joe McElderry (who is signed to Simon's record label, SyCo) had to settle for spot number two, thanks to a grassroots Facebook campaign, "Rage Against The X Factor."

It all started with married RATM fans Jon and Tracy Morter's Facebook-based protest, which eventually gained the support of big-name rockers like the Foo Fighters' Dave Grohl, Paul McCartney, and Rage's own Tom Morello. The goal of the campaign was to make RATM's 1992 political anthem "Killing In The Name" Britain's Christmas number one, instead of the expected X Factor single. And, incredibly, this campaign WORKED: "Killing In The Name" topped the U.K. singles chart this week with 500,000 copies sold, compared to number two entry Joe McElderry's sales of 450,000. For the first time in five years, an X Factor champion did not snag Britain's coveted Christmas number one spot.

A shocked Jon Morter told British music magazine NME: "It just goes to show if you use social networking in the right way, you can do it." Rumors circulated in the U.K. press that Simon Cowell was so impressed with this campaign that he offered Jon and Tracy Morter marketing jobs at SyCo, but the Morters turned him down. Hey...maybe one of them can take Simon's job on American Idol instead!

In other Idol-related news, season 4 winner Carrie Underwood got engaged to pro hockey player Mike Fisher, her boyfriend of one year and the man she declared in her recent Play On album liner notes to be "the most amazing addition to my life." And season 3 Idol star Jennifer Hudson, who just gave birth to her first child four months ago (the father is fellow reality star David "Punk" Otunga, of I Love New York fame), was rumored to already be pregnant again--but a J.Hud rep quickly squashed that gossip, telling Access Hollywood: "Contrary to what has been falsely reported, Jennifer Hudson is not pregnant. Jennifer leaves in April for South Africa where she will portray Winnie Mandela in the feature film Winnie. It is a commitment she is excited about and takes very seriously. Jennifer is currently in the studio recording her second album and this is the only delivery she is looking forward to in 2010."

Regardless, we wish both Jennifer and Carrie good luck in the new year with their future endeavors, both personal and professional.

On that note, congratulations are also in order to eldest Jonas Brother Kevin, who married his sweetheart Danielle Delesea in a French-style chateau in suburban New York this week, with his brothers/bandmates Joe and Nick co-serving as the best men. Although, of course, for some heartbroken JoBros fangirls, the news of Kevin Jonas no longer being single may be more tragic than this week's Simon Cowell bombshell.

Unfortunately, there was some truly sad news this week. Troubled on/off Aerosmith frontman Steven Tyler entered rehab to battle his painkiller addiction; troubled "Rehab" star Amy Winehouse was charged with assault; troubled rapper was Kid Cudi held at gunpoint by Los Angeles police in an unfortunate case of mistaken identity; and, most troublingly, Brittany Murphy mysteriously died of a cardiac arrest at only age 32.

While that last tragic story might not seem music-related per se, Brittany's death is a big loss to both the film and music world. Not only did she play Eminem's love interest (aka the "Kim Mathers" role) in 8 Mile, but she was a vocalist in her own right, and one of the few singing actresses to make a credible crossover into music: She scored a club hit in 2006 alongside techno guru Paul Oakenfold (pictured right) with the floor-filler "Faster Kill Pussycat," performed in Pussycat Dolls revues, and contributed covers of Queen's "Somebody To Love" and Earth, Wind & Fire's "Boogie Wonderland" to the Happy Feet soundtrack. It is a shame that such a talent is gone, especially in this tough year that has been filled with the losses of so many showbiz greats. In future years, Brittany Murphy may have developed into a full-fledged recording artist, had she chosen to pursue music more seriously. But we will never know what might have been. She will be missed.

And on that sad note, we will sign off. Have a wonderful Christmas week with your loved ones, and see you next week for our final blog of 2009.


1) Brittany Murphy Dies - The singer/actress was only 32.

2) Simon Cowell May Leave Idol - The reality judge's own brother says season 9 will be Simon's last.

3) Steven Tyler Still Living On The Edge - The Aerosmith singer enters rehab for painkiller addiction.

4) Kevin Jonas Marries - Sorry girls, he's officially off the market.

5) Underwood Gets Carrie'd Away - The country Idol is now engaged.

6) Rage Against The X Factor - The X Factor winner's single is kept out of the number one chart spot by a 1992 Rage Against The Machine song.

7) You Know That She's No Good - Amy Winehouse is charged with assault.

8) Kid Cudi Held At Gunpoint By LAPD - Problems keep coming for the troubled rapper.

9) "And I Am Telling You...I'm Not Pregnant" - Rumors of Jennifer Hudson's second pregnancy prove untrue.

10) Conrad Murray Ready For His Close-Up? - A documentary is being planned on Michael Jackson's controversial doctor.


Follow me on Twitter 

Follow Yahoo! Music on Twitter

View Comments